Instead of Gorkss...

[RussRanger]

Who would you swap for Puncheon?

Personally, I still feel we are mugging ourselves off and there are at least half a dozen players we could swap instead of him. So what deal would you strike?

[Toni German]

3 Leon Clarkes

[Mellowhoop]

Don't think he's worth gorkks and money

[W12hoops]

Clarke, Borrowdale, Vine, pellicori and £450.000(full price)

[LOOPYHOOP]

I hope there's no truth in gorkks going the other way,I'd rather it was Ramage.

[ollyhoops]

Clarke/Borrowdale

[MattyRangers]

We need defenders alot more than we need attackers at the mo so, to me, it makes no sense. We should try and clear some dead wood and chuck in Clarke,Vine, Pellicori and Alberti plus a small cash sum for him if anything....

...If only eh!

[Ginger Ninja]

Ramage. Gorkss is far better.

[Yousef]

Vine because is taking too much money.

[MattyRangers]

Vine because is taking too much money.

Hense why we cant get rid of him. no other club will match the wages he is on here at he is more than happy to not play and sit collecting his wage every week.

[geejaybee]

Can't see the logic in part exchanging Gorkss for puncheon.Gorkss was our most consistant CB last season and our defenders are thin on the ground.If Southampton rate Puncheon at £1m then its them that should be offering their man + £2m for Gorkss.Even then I wouldn't want to see him go.

[Dazzer1977]

Vine, Agyemang, Clarke & Rowlands

[Nodge70]

We should be looking to get money from Southampton for taking Puncheon with Gorkks, not vice versa. Ludicrously over values Puncheon and criminally under values Gorkks.

Surely Southampton should be all over Rowlands and Cook?

[72bus]

offer them damage,clarke and big pat . by the way jason punchoen isnt premiership class

[sirpiechucker]

We should be looking to get money from Southampton for taking Puncheon with Gorkks, not vice versa. Ludicrously over values Puncheon and criminally under values Gorkks.

Surely Southampton should be all over Rowlands and Cook?

Agree about the values but arguably where Saints are weakest is their defence so I'm not surprised they would want Kaspars.