If Walker was left footed, who would you you play at LB?

[Olly]

Speed or experience?

[rockandroll]

LB doesnt have to be left footed! its not a copyright thingy..

[Toni German]

It's a bit like asking, "If Colin was a #### would you sack him?"

He isn't, therefore the whole question is meaningless.

[Jeffro]

What a very strange question?
If Messi wanted to play for QPR , what would you say?

[qblockpete]

Are you ssuggesting he could go left and Orr goes right?

Think a player Walker could play either flank

[Jeffro]

Are you ssuggesting he could go left and Orr goes right?

Think a player Walker could play either flank

I dont think he is pete as he has asked theoretically if Walker was "Left footed", basically asking would we prefer a left footed Walker to Clint Hill??

Bizarre

[qblockpete]

okay fair enough, in that case if Cook was right footed he could play on the right

[Ginger Ninja]

Speed or experience?

do you mean should we play orr on the right, walker on the left and drop clint hill?
if so, then im not so sure. clint hill has made some fantastic saving tackles in the last few games and i think his experience is invaluable. dont change a defence that has let in 1 goal out of 3 since walker has been here imo. orr is a good player and i think the competition for RB between him and walker is healthy.

[rtone]

okay fair enough, in that case if Cook was right footed he could play on the right

no

[qprted]

to go to your origional question

i would have clint hill becauase hes one mean dude,he would kill to win that ball


so clint wins it for me

[Hoopaman]

okay fair enough, in that case if Cook was right footed he could play on the right

Different for wingers, cookie on the right could cut in on his left. Full backs cutting in to use there good foot doesn't really work and loses width from the back. Any football commentator should know that...

What do they say about the blind leading the blind...

[waterbuffalo]

I would always go for speed, if you are late on a tackle, free-kick, boom, goal.

[Olly]

sorry guys, I was thinking about the choice between hill and walker at LB. Walker made a speedy challenge on steve morrison when it looked as if he was thru when we played millwall.