Cook

[qpr-buzsaky]

If it was anybody else apart from cook who we had bought, everyone would have been blaming gianni saying how s*** a deal it was. Big wages, been out injured for ages and not actually that great. Just putting it into perspective.

[stainrodisalegend]

sentiment aside, purely in terms of games played, goals/ assists/ general contribution as against cost he must be one of the worst signings the new regime has made (and there is stiff competition for that particular acolayde).

[Ric-Roc]

I do like Cookie but to be fair he's not that good. Think Hogan is a much better winger, quick sharp & hungry. Cook could be out the door this summer I hear.

[qpr-buzsaky]

sentiment aside, purely in terms of games played, goals/ assists/ general contribution as against cost he must be one of the worst signings the new regime has made (and there is stiff competition for that particular acolayde).

Agreed.

[JudoRanger]

what basis is hogan a better winger?

he doesnt cross
he doesnt beat his man
he is too lightweight
he doesnt tackle

i cant think of a single thing he does that would make me put him in ahead of cook.

[qpr-buzsaky]

Cook is better then hogan, but if it hadnt been cook and had been anyone else everyone would have said it was one of the worst deals in the flavio era

[dpmd]

Was he wearing ice skates instead of boots today?

[NW9_RANGER]

what basis is hogan a better winger?

he doesnt cross
he doesnt beat his man
he is too lightweight
he doesnt tackle

i cant think of a single thing he does that would make me put him in ahead of cook.

what are u talking about?

[Ric-Roc]

what basis is hogan a better winger?

he doesnt cross
he doesnt beat his man
he is too lightweight
he doesnt tackle

i cant think of a single thing he does that would make me put him in ahead of cook.

Delusional comes to mind. I take it you were not at the game today to see Hogan whip in some lovely balls that the forwards never capitalised on. Cook is supposedly in his prime age wise yet does next to nothing with the ball. Young eager hungry raw Hogan for me all day over Cook.

[Factamondo]

if cookie wasn't an 'r's fan'........mmmmm.....methinks our attitudes towards him a trifle different???

[THE FLYING COW]

SOME

SOME PLAYERS REALLY SUFFER WITH INCONSISTANCY,AND COOKIE IS ONE OF THOSE PLAYERS..............he has so much ability but he just cant be consistant................AS MUCH AS I LOVE WARNOCK I WISHED HE WOULD RE INSTATE BUZSACKY AS A GOAL SCORING WINGER................i remember when he scored 16 goals in a season.................buzsacky has one problem he seas himself as a midfield player

[RamseyR]

what basis is hogan a better winger?

he doesnt cross
he doesnt beat his man
he is too lightweight
he doesnt tackle

i cant think of a single thing he does that would make me put him in ahead of cook.

err....not always crocked!

[HammersmithR]

Cook came on too late yesterday to affect the game. Hogan was poor and should have been subbed much earlier. Not sure what Warnock sees in Hogan. He is too inconsistent.

[Jeff]

I don't want to sh*t on your riff there DFE, but Buzsaky has NEVER scored 16 a season - this season his best ever season (07/08 with us) was 10 goals. and the reason that he sees himself as a midfield player is the reason that EVERYONE sees him as a midfield player - HE IS!

[ollyhoops]

Well most of the team this season has been off form.... so we could say that with most players not just Cook.

I would keep Ephraim & Cook as i'm sure next season they'll both be ready.