If I was Liam Kelly

[WeAreQPR12]

Don't know what he was doing with the penalty all that dancing around on the line, he was still dancing when the bloke just tucked it in the corner, just try saving the penalty, your not Fu(king on strictly come dancing

Haha can't be any worse than David James though

[LoftusRoadLad]

If he saved it then people would be saying he done well! And as for not diving, he must have thought the bloke would smash it down the middle like so many do these days.

If he saved it the ref would have ordered a retake. Don't we have rules ?

[qpr4life]

No, he is probably not but I don't like what I see so far anyway..

How many games has he played, in-fact how many minutes?

[erikmata]

Two plus a few cup games I think. Of those I have only seen bits of but as an old gk, I am not convinced, yet. Hopefully I am wrong..

[qpr4life]

Two plus a few cup games I think. Of those I have only seen bits of but as an old gk, I am not convinced, yet. Hopefully I am wrong..

So, you havent really seen him nor has he had a chance.

[erikmata]

I have seen both games in the league, plus bits and pieces of the cup games.. we'll see.

[qpr4life]

I have seen both games in the league, plus bits and pieces of the cup games.. we'll see.

Its 3 games, in which he's not really made many bad mistakes?

[erikmata]

Still not overly impressed..

[Kit]

Does have a habit of running off his line, should have stayed back with their first goal, made up the strikers mind for him ! But some decent saves early on too.

[erikmata]

Yes indeed, all over the box, doesn’t look safe with hands or feet. Imho he is not good enough for a top-10 team in the Championship but I am sure management knows about this. Hopefully JL gets his confidence back soon, then he’ll be back between the posts.. unless we are bringing someone in.

[Shania]

He needs a few more games behind a better drilled defence.

[knocker]

I think the only thing sure about our goalkeeper situation after watching both Lumley and Kelly is that we urgently need a new one.

[Jimmy Floyd Rabbit]

Made a great stop down low early on.

Those saying he came out to early for the first goal i disagree. BFG got absolutely burned for pace and the keeper HAS to come out to cut the angle and he did come out fast. The striker just slotted it away well.

I thought he done alright with good handling. Just needs to be less erratic in his positioning at times.

No better or or worse than Lumley IMO.

[knocker]

Made a great stop down low early on.

Those saying he came out to early for the first goal i disagree. BFG got absolutely burned for pace and the keeper HAS to come out to cut the angle and he did come out fast. The striker just slotted it away well.

I thought he done alright with good handling. Just needs to be less erratic in his positioning at times.

No better or or worse than Lumley IMO.

Agree no better or worse than Lumley. We can surely do better.

[Jimmy Floyd Rabbit]

Agree no better or worse than Lumley. We can surely do better.

Sounds daft but I'd go back in for Smithies in January.

Didnt play a single PL game last season, started this season and now dropped again.