Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Hopeful of players coming in

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Insider
    Bronze Seat
    • Jun 2011
    • 523

    #1

    Hopeful of players coming in

    What do we reckon? Would you lot be happy with

    Collins
    Routledge
    Thorne

    Or we missing something else?
  • cross it Dave
    Silver Seat
    • Sep 2009
    • 3810

    #2
    Collins and Thorne yes, Routledge no.
    I have supported Rangers for 55 seasons, since March 1969.

    Comment

    • Insider
      Bronze Seat
      • Jun 2011
      • 523

      #3
      Thorne would be brilliant in front of the defence. Piano player for me and seems to hopefully be staying fit

      Comment

      • lincoln ranger
        Bronze Seat
        • Jul 2009
        • 942

        #4
        New Left back? Bidwell does lose concentration easily, e.g. losing his man at the back post for the killer 2nd Brizzle goal last week, and for me he doesn't get forward enough. Nose bleed time when he goes beyond the half way line! Apart from Haameleinen, he's also got no competition for the number 3 jersey has he? Probably become complacent as his inclusion is always a given

        Comment

        • Timmy the Doc
          Silver Seat
          • Jan 2012
          • 3193

          #5
          Originally posted by lincoln ranger
          New Left back? Bidwell does lose concentration easily, e.g. losing his man at the back post for the killer 2nd Brizzle goal last week, and for me he doesn't get forward enough. Nose bleed time when he goes beyond the half way line! Apart from Haameleinen, he's also got no competition for the number 3 jersey has he? Probably become complacent as his inclusion is always a given
          Bidwell has had a difficult start but was one of our best players end of last season.

          Comment

          • Artful
            Bronze Seat
            • May 2009
            • 772

            #6
            Originally posted by lincoln ranger
            New Left back? Bidwell does lose concentration easily, e.g. losing his man at the back post for the killer 2nd Brizzle goal last week, and for me he doesn't get forward enough. Nose bleed time when he goes beyond the half way line! Apart from Haameleinen, he's also got no competition for the number 3 jersey has he? Probably become complacent as his inclusion is always a given
            Whoever the left back is they need support in front of them, playing Eze in front of him means he is more often than not overloaded as Eze ball watches and loses his man very easily. Happened again yesterday on several occasions until he was swapped with Freeman.

            Comment

            • QPROslo
              Silver Seat
              • Dec 2010
              • 1137

              #7
              Bidwell was "steady Eddie" last season - not spectacular in any ways, but never weak like now. I think is has to do with the way the team is set up and organized more than the fact Bidwell isn't good enough.

              Comment

              • Ramsgate Hoop
                Bronze Seat
                • Mar 2009
                • 405

                #8
                Originally posted by lincoln ranger
                New Left back? Bidwell does lose concentration easily, e.g. losing his man at the back post for the killer 2nd Brizzle goal last week, and for me he doesn't get forward enough. Nose bleed time when he goes beyond the half way line! Apart from Haameleinen, he's also got no competition for the number 3 jersey has he? Probably become complacent as his inclusion is always a given
                Bidwell has been getting over run because people haven't been tracking back. Almost cost us again yesterday. If someone like Pawel was playing in front of him we would look more solid I believe

                Comment

                • Shania
                  C Club
                  • Apr 2010
                  • 23699

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Timmy the Doc

                  Bidwell has had a difficult start but was one of our best players end of last season.
                  More often than not, one of our scapegoats
                  QPR
                  Best team in the world
                  Sort of

                  Comment

                  • Shania
                    C Club
                    • Apr 2010
                    • 23699

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Ramsgate Hoop

                    Bidwell has been getting over run because people haven't been tracking back. Almost cost us again yesterday. If someone like Pawel was playing in front of him we would look more solid I believe
                    This. And that`s why other teams target his area. Imo, that is.
                    QPR
                    Best team in the world
                    Sort of

                    Comment

                    • corbray
                      Silver Seat
                      • Feb 2016
                      • 3030

                      #11
                      i like bidwell as most of the time he's one of our most consistent and composed players. his form will pick up again so it'd be unfair to write him off right away imo.

                      i actually liked him when he played cb last season too, thought he was pretty decent there

                      Comment

                      • lincoln ranger
                        Bronze Seat
                        • Jul 2009
                        • 942

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Ramsgate Hoop

                        Bidwell has been getting over run because people haven't been tracking back. Almost cost us again yesterday. If someone like Pawel was playing in front of him we would look more solid I believe
                        Fair one, but he just doesn't do enough for me. In this day and age that full backs have to get forward more to support attacks, he rarely provides us with this. Yes he may have been a steady Eddie last season, but I'd still want more from my full backs. Wszolek should be starting every game RMF, perhaps if we played a 4-4-2 and the LMF role was given to Freeman or Smyth, our LB would have that support. 4-3-3 means there is a lot of gaps in MF and the lack of support to the defence when opposition attack, especially in wide roles, putting more pressure on the full backs

                        Comment

                        • maidstone_hoop
                          Gold Seat
                          • May 2009
                          • 6718

                          #13
                          Would be happy with all three to be honest but Collins and Thorne would be very welcome additions indeed.

                          indont actually necessarily think we need a lb to replace Bidwell but do we have adequate cover if he gets injured or anyone really pushing him to maintain his place.

                          Comment

                          • davieqpr
                            Silver Seat
                            • Mar 2011
                            • 2804

                            #14
                            If Bidwell gets forward then no one covers him. Opposition often put two men on him when attacking as Eze has a tendency to ball watch.
                            Routledge is not the player anymore that people remember.

                            Comment

                            • CroydonCaptainJack
                              Gold Seat
                              • Jan 2011
                              • 6141

                              #15
                              Bidwell has had a few bad games but imo was our most improved player last aeason.

                              Comment

                              Working...