tommy smith or beckford in jan

[jackqpr]

who would you go for in jan?

[jackqpr]

smith is proven in this league so for the january transfer window id go for him

[MYU]

He's only scored 17 once in a season and is he what we really need?

More...

[sirpiechucker]

He's only scored 17 once in a season and is he what we really need?

More...

How many has Beckford scored at this level? Even Samuel De Carmine has scored more goals in the Championship than Beckford has.

Smith doesn't just score he assists and leads. He is an intelligent footballer who would be an asset to have.

[kingo]

Smith proven at this level and in the Prem.

[MYU]

How many has Beckford scored at this level? Even Samuel De Carmine has scored more goals in the Championship than Beckford has.

Smith doesn't just score he assists and leads. He is an intelligent footballer who would be an asset to have.

Sorry I was not saying Beckford was the guy, all I'm saying is that we need someone who can finish, we have a team full of players who can assist.

Not saying that Smith is no good at all, if we can remove Vine and bring in Smith then it could be a good move.

[sirpiechucker]

Sorry I was not saying Beckford was the guy, all I'm saying is that we need someone who can finish, we have a team full of players who can assist.

Not saying that Smith is no good at all, if we can remove Vine and bring in Smith then it could be a good move.

He will score goals but like many players he was been playing for a poor side for so long he didn't score at a rate that he is capable of.

[qpr-buzsaky]

Both would be great at this level, although I think Beckford would propably be better than smith but either would be great

[W6hoops]

smithy

[Mr Lofty]

Both if I had the choice. Both would be a big improvement.

[hemelhoop]

Would like both, but Beckford would be first choice.