Discuss Adel Taarabt

[MYU]

He can run through the opposition, in fact he'll walk the ball into the net and then take on all the fans but he wont pass the ball.

What do you make of him so far?

[Robsondinho]

friking genius...will go on to play for a top european side. Privilage to watch.

now wheres my tin hat

[qblockpete]

Has played some stinkers, his shooting can be wayward to say the least and he does frustrate me, because he often holds onto the ball too long.

Apart from that, he is best player we have at the club.

[conners]

The guy is streets ahead of any player we have at our club. Highly unlikely that we will score when he is not on the pitch and puts the likes of Routledge to shame.

God forbid that we lose him.

[Youvebeenrangered]

Frustrates the **** out of me, he needs to learn when to try his silky skills and when to pick the right pass at the right time, he's young and has alot to learn i guess....

I cant put into words how annoying i find it when were 2-1 down against watford and he has about 3 chances to put the ball in the box but doesnt do it.

If he wants to continue with his silky skills and what not great, but do it when were 3-0 up, do it when its not going to cost us points.

If he can be abit more of a team player then he could have it all.

Insaying that he has alot of quality, and id rather have him than not.

[Fez]

Rough diamond!

[roose]

An amazing player that may make it as one of the best ever, or might end up playing second division french football as a show pony.

Part of me want's us to send him back to spurs as i think he must be upsetting other players by not passing but i would miss his fantastic skill.

[Sam-QPR]

doesn't matter if he is the best player in the world if he doesn't play as part of the team hes no good to us.

[Quaz]

greedy and not a team player.....only here for personal gain.

[themodfather]

a talent
won't pass which is affecting the TEAM
pacy and it'd be a shame if he wastes his skills
to me looks weighty and imo struggles to finish a full 90 mins.
should he stay or go?????
if it means a chance of going up if he leaves..cheerio
if we miss out cos he won't pass...and stays..oh dear.

needs an older head to have words on the pitch, to see so many qpr players throw their arms up in the air thru frustration he don't pass....not good, alan smith a brilliant striker for leics and arsenal, noted this.

[EYR]

Plays for himself "Look at me,sign me up" .Maybe if he was are our own player he would be more team orientated,i dont know?

Undoubted quality and great to watch when things are going your way.

[paulmason]

Send him back. He will never be part of the team because he thinks he is the team.

[SmartRs]

He was the same at Spurs, that's why they loaned him out. He's not a team player, rarely passes and when he does it usually takes team mates by surprise.

He has a great talent but he needs to look up and see where his team mates are. When he has the ball, you can see opposition players getting drawn towards him, leaving some of his team mates in a better position. If only he could appreciate that football is a team game, he'd be a world beater. He's still young so maybe there is time for him yet but I doubt it as he's always been like this.

Harry Redknapp is a good judge of a player. Would he really lend him out with such skill if he thought that he'd be able to make him into a team player? Nope.

You can see how frustrated some of the other players are with him. They take up good positions and the ball doesn't come their way. Personally, I'd send him back because, despite his skill, he does nothing for morale or team play.

[pkloft]

what Quaz said :byebye:

but.................... a very skillful player

[BennyBoyRs]

Definately NOT the best player at the club. Not by a long shot because he's too greedy. His shooting is poor most of the time and he can't/won't pass wind. Comfortably the most skillful player I've seen with my own eyes down the Bush, but that doesn't make him a great player. His greediness costs us more than it helps. He tries stuff that doesn't come off way too often and even does it in our own half which usually leads to a dangerous attack from the opposition which he simply throws his arms around instead of tracking back.

A luxury player who is far from expendable.