Steven Reid

[Receed R]

I know its impossible to judge a player on only one game but if we had the oppurtunity should we sign him permanently?

There is an article in the People today saying bolton are looking to buy him in january for around 500k

Thoughts

[NewarkR]

Not on yesterday. Still time though.

[BennyBoyRs]

My thoughts are that he's quality. He's just returned from a second serious injury and needs game practice.

[Rich]

Not for me based on what I witnessed yesterday. Watson on the other hand played some lovely balls around.

[Quaz]

personally i think we should be putting more faith in faurlin.......

[rangersroar]

personally i think we should be putting more faith in faurlin.......

Spot on. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[NewarkR]

I'm waiting for the news that Faurlin had a knock yesterday.

Otherwise the decision to take him off and leave tweedle dee and tweedle dum on is astonishing.

[Youvebeenrangered]

personally i think we should be putting more faith in faurlin.......

Agree...Hes quality, but unfortunatley he seems to be the one who allways makes way.

[Receed R]

Agree...Hes quality, but unfortunatley he seems to be the one who allways makes way.

if thats the case what was the point in us signing him in first place?

[ahR]

A few thoughts.......

Agree...Hes quality, but unfortunatley he seems to be the one who allways makes way.

This is just my take on things but, based on the fact that Wigan and Blackburn will want their players to get fit and find some form, surely part of the agreement is that they play no matter what unless injured. Thus, Faurlin being relatively young, new to English football and our player means that he is the most dispensible?

It's unlikely that Big Sam is going to let Reid go out on loan if he is going to be a bit part player. With this said though it does seem quite extraordinary that Reid started having only joined a couple of days earlier. I'd have thought that he would have started on the bench and came on as a sub when or if required... But hey, it's not my decision!!

[swanleyhoop]

Think it should be Faurlin with Reid Or Watson -- although too many of Watson's balls are half a yard too short (!) and he was caught in possession a few times -- and has been every time he's played.
Reid for me looked a class above, considering he's on his way back and rusty.

[Youvebeenrangered]

if thats the case what was the point in us signing him in first place?

well thats the question! Does well then gets taken off, its almost like hes rated as the worst of the best cos he's allways the first casualty...

I think hes great, but watson and reid are bigger names.