Would you swop Stewart for Big Dan?

[Bernie's Barnet]

Plus, wouldn't ****tu be off to the African Cup of Nations with Nigeria?

[qblockpete]

I'm pretty certain we are NOT after Sh.ittu but I would have him like shot. I think we need defenders after Gorkss and Connolly, you have Stewart and Hall who have not set the world alight and with Borrowdale ill, we had no cover left back apart from Ramage.

We have goals in the team, but sometimes we look vulnerable at the back.

All about opinions

[Mutley]

Immaterial as neither are good enough to be a first choice.

[Robsondinho]

If you asked me about Carlisle, I'd say he's part of a defence conceding over 3 goals a game away from home in the Prem and is clearly out of his depth.

If you asked me about ****tu, I'd say he played one season in the Prem in a defence that got relegated, and has since moved to a Prem team where he hardly plays, isn't a first choice and at his age is not likely to improve enough to make the step either.

If you asked me about centre backs we need to look at, I'd say they have to be better than Connolly and Gorkss, and ****tu doesn't qualify.

And finally, if you asked me where we need to strengthen in defence, I'd say the priorities definitely are not at centre half, they are at Left Back where we only have one below average CCC option available to us, and then at Right Back, where we need a Right Back to play, not a fifth choice central midfielder or a converted, one paced centre back.

What he said

[Robbo]

What they said. ^^^^^^

[stan_bowles]

bet some big no pace lump Italian turns up sooner or later.

Paulo Maldini it is then.

[Funky]

I like Big Dan think he would be an excellent addition to our squad.

Not a starter by any means but Hall Stewart, Connolly Gorks and ****tu would create healthy competition.

But other positions are more of a priority.

LEFT BACK!!!

[stan_bowles]

Yeah,would rather concentrate on better full backs first.

[Nodge70]

Never rated Stewart.

Would get Dan back in a flash.

Big YES from me.

[Sam-QPR]

100% yes

[Robbo]

****tu is better than Stewart or Fitz Hall.

But none of those three are better than Connolly or Gorkks.

Unfortunately, (just like Simpson) you can't guarantee that they will be fit for the rest of the season. Far from it.

But at least we have cover in the middle. Unlike at left back.

[stainrodisalegend]

Agree with every word of that Robbo

[Youvebeenrangered]

****tu wouldnt be the worst idea. He's better than hall or stewart!

[m_cooper]

according to ****tu,he is above this division anyway;times have moved on and the calibre of strikers in this division would easily out fox big dane on the floor so it is a no from me;probably why he is not getting starts

[BennyBoyRs]

****tu is better than Stewart or Fitz Hall.

But none of those three are better than Connolly or Gorkks.

Unfortunately, (just like Simpson) you can't guarantee that they will be fit for the rest of the season. Far from it.

But at least we have cover in the middle. Unlike at left back.

I agreed up until the left back cover