Manning

[1973 ranger]

Agree about Manning and hope the progress continues he could become a very good player. I like Carroll and thought he would have a good future in the game.

[corbray]

Agree about Manning and hope the progress continues he could become a very good player. I like Carroll and thought he would have a good future in the game.

Same. Carrol was lightweight for us but i still woulda thought he had the potential to be a future england international

[1973 ranger]

He was a young lad who was out on loan to aid his development. Very rarely gave the ball away and great 1 touch play.

[bakes8]

Same. Carrol was lightweight for us but i still woulda thought he had the potential to be a future england international

Neat and tidy player but weaker than a wet paper bag. Looked good for Swansea the other week but he's no spring chicken anymore. Nowhere near good enough for international football (Imo)