Sherwood vs Clement

[luca]

Definitely Clement.

[Fordy]

Both would be just keeping the seat warm for the next one. Lets face it we haven't got good enough players to get promoted, just want to see some attacking football at home and actually go for it.

[Nick]

Neither for me!..... would both be risky appointments, something we dont need. Yes both much much better shouts than the previous 2 apprentices. But never the less, stll risky. We need a more experienced manager imho.

[stanistheman]

Neither for me!..... would both be risky appointments, something we dont need. Yes both much much better shouts than the previous 2 apprentices. But never the less, stll risky. We need a more experienced manager imho.

Then it would have to be Curbishley as I doubt that Allardyce or Pearson would come to work under a DoF nor would Hoddle, after possibly being overlooked when Redkrapp quit.

[spiderman]

Both would take time to get things right and we all know you dont get that at QPR .
So both will fail imho.
Need someone who gets instant results and forget the future building.
Pearson or Big Sam.

Spot on.

[corbray]

Clement for me 100%. Didn't come to mind straight away but when he was linked it changed my mind. young manager with bags of potential and a great resume too, his link to the club is what really sold it to me, qpr supporter and the son of dave clement is like a match made in heaven

[Ginger Ninja]

Both would take time to get things right and we all know you dont get that at QPR .
So both will fail imho.
Need someone who gets instant results and forget the future building.
Pearson or Big Sam.

You're actually spot on lol.

[1QPRDK]

You're actually spot on lol.

Yes, one year of building should be enough. End of. Big Sam it is then

[The General]

Sky not even mentioning Timmy now .

Saying Clement Zola Cotterall

[The General]

Big Sam the Bung will not come to QPR unfortunatly

Syco Pearson will not come to QPR unfortunatly

Both would be my first choices too but they won't come with Les as Director of Chaos

[stanistheman]

Both would take time to get things right and we all know you dont get that at QPR .
So both will fail imho.
Need someone who gets instant results and forget the future building.
Pearson or Big Sam.

True about lack of time at QPR, but am not sure that Pearson would get instant results - failed at Hull and was a great success at Derby where his team couldn’t even score a goal let alone win games.

[winalotto]

Who would attract better players to our club?

Hard to say really , it's not just the coach it's the whole set up now , financial terms, length of contract, training facilities, all goes together to attract players, if it was just the two names I would say Sherwood in this country

[Del]

Neither for me!..... would both be risky appointments, something we dont need. Yes both much much better shouts than the previous 2 apprentices. But never the less, stll risky. We need a more experienced manager imho.

No logic in that whatsoever. You talk like these two have a wealth of management experience. Let's see, Sherwood a few months at Spurs and a few #### poor months at Villa, and Clement a few months at Derby. Both have failed to produce or meet expectations.

If they don't fall in the "Apprentice" bracket as you put it, I don't know who would...

[maidstone_hoop]

Sky not even mentioning Timmy now .

Saying Clement Zola Cotterall

So they don't mention Tim, yet have suspended betting on him lol

[Hubble]

Sherwood is a ####ing clown. Seriously, people talking about JFH being a joke, well if this tw@t takes over, I'm outta here. I can't take this circus any more.