Why is this site hated by so many R supporters

[Stanley]

Ive seen better Stan.

Better summaries you mean, Manx? All about opinions of course.

Yes I agree with you it can be cliquey but as Hubble says that applies to most sites, and something that's difficult to ever completely eradicate.

[Manx Hoop]

i added another line Stan.

Its ok place, or we wouldnt be here.

[Rebel R's]

This is still the site I keep on eye on most on transfer day