is vine good enough???

[Factamondo]

i ask as the lad seems to have lost that zest n sparkle that he had when he first came.i know he aint an out n out goalscorer but a foil for another striker but is he going to help us forward or do we offer him and aggyispants in exchange for say a gary hooper or craig mackel smith type player???

[nuffieldranger]

Not long back from a major injury give the lad some time

[Factamondo]

yes thats right but lets be frank.........the lad couldnt cut the mustard on a regular basis at pompey or brum!!

[Tarbie]

Rowan Vine on form is one of the best players in the Championship. He is coming back from a horror injury and needs time to get back to form!

[superhoop67]

needs to improve pretty sharpish , and stop strolling round like a prima donna

[Factamondo]

needs to improve pretty sharpish , and stop strolling round like a prima donna

thankyou that is my 'factamondo' reguarding viney..........he seems to be on cruise control too much!!

[HammersmithR]

I think he is doing fine at the moment. Still getting match practice but he plays for the team.

[superhoop67]

He played towards end of last season , a full pre season and 12 games into this season . How much longer is needed

[Quaz]

He played towards end of last season , a full pre season and 12 games into this season . How much longer is needed

why the rush....is he holding back the team...i think not...also what other player is there to replace him?

[shania]

We should buy:byebye: Macrail :exciting:Smith AND KEEP Vino!!:red_heart::red_heart:


Macrail Smith would be the last piece of the puzzle . He seems to impress. But would cost us a fortune.:tired:

[Robsondinho]

Agree with Facto...good player on his day but imo not good enough for the prem or top 6-10 ccc.

[Quaz]

Agree with Facto...good player on his day but imo not good enough for the prem or top 6-10 ccc.

how many of our team are actually good enough for the prem......wouldn't be playing for us right now if they were

[Factamondo]

true quazz...........maybe buzz n routledge could get in a lower prem team like foooolem!!!

[Quaz]

true quazz...........maybe buzz n routledge could get in a lower prem team like foooolem!!!

not so sure mate......think many would get a rude awakening about how good our players really are.......we will see against newcastle wednesday........

[Nik29]

Thought he did well Yesterday, set up Watson's goal.. as a fan, it really shows how much he wants to score.. shame he's cutting a pretty frustrated figure at the mo.

Also, compare Vine to Pat or Pels.. that's why he is starting!