Tom Carroll

[Factamondo]

im affraid 45 games in n redknapp still aint a scooby who our best eleven/formation is!

[West Acton]

I still think he'll carve out a very good career.

At what level and where Deeps. I cannot believe if Spurs have had him watched while playing for us will have STC anywhere near their squad

[Joe90]

The weakest link in the team is Dunn and Carroll. Get rid of them an we'll be solid.

[DeepcutHoop]

At what level and where Deeps. I cannot believe if Spurs have had him watched while playing for us will have STC anywhere near their squad

It wouldn't be entirely surprising for someone who QPR fans didn't rate to go on and do well elsewhere would it?

[CroydonCaptainJack]

That's the way we play as a team. All season. Percentage football rather than risky passes. It's why our stats nearly always show us with high possession and low shots.

I still maintain that Tom Carroll (and I admit he has not been as good as I'd hoped he would be) gets a disproportionate amount of stick compared to other midfielders.

Just my opinion, and will be irrelevant in a few games when he goes back to Spurs. I still think he'll carve out a very good career.

I agree Deep

[West Acton]

It wouldn't be entirely surprising for someone who QPR fans didn't rate to go on and do well elsewhere would it?

But where and what level?? Not only here he has failed to deliver hes not thought of much at Orient or Derby

[Shania]

He played very good against Forest.

[Factamondo]

the lad is a kid still and may train on but we need a henry lansbury,josh macheachran,lewis mcguigan type player!

[NotDannyColes]

He's not great, decent with the ball but shocking without it. Would rather have another fighter (Karl Henry) in midfield than him.

[Factamondo]

barton/jenas/henry............two outta.............but redknapp loves carroll for some reason

[Rangers77]

Hopefully Jenas will be fit and able to start beside Barton in the play offs!

Not the biggest fan of JJ, but I actually think this is key to us winning the play offs or not. I think Barton's less effective playing with Carroll. Second half yesterday Carroll got the ball on the left with acres of space in front of him; he carried it a mere five years then, under no pressure, cut inside and passed it backwards to Barton. Seen that oh so many times.....

[tommyqpr]

The weakest link in the team is Dunn and Carroll. Get rid of them an we'll be solid.

Think this is a slight exaggeration to say the least. Carroll replaced with another of our cms doesn't automatically make us solid - Henry/JJ haven't exactly been that much better this season.

[QPR1976]

Someone please, please enlighten me as to why he is so highly regarded by Redknapp? One of the most infuriating players of the season. Absolutely no physical presence, no vision on the ball and an embarrassing reluctance to get stuck in. At times it's like watching a 12 year-old run around aimlessly in the centre of the pitch. One moment yesterday summed him up: receives the ball in a decent position on the left flank and then slices it into the stand like a Sunday League player. He is just shocking. Start him in the play-offs and we'll just get overrun in midfield. What on earth does the old toad see in him? Could it be a dodgy 'arrangement' with Spurs I wonder? I just can't understand how he is the first name on the team sheet every week.

I can't. Generally he's disappointed me. But in the interest of a balanced view....

Did you have the same feelings after the Forest game, when with 3 assists, he was arguably the MotM ?

And how do you know he's the first name on the team sheet ? I bet that's Green.

Otherwise, a fair assessment.

[West Acton]

I can't. Generally he's disappointed me. But in the interest of a balanced view....

Did you have the same feelings after the Forest game, when with 3 assists, he was arguably the MotM ?

And how do you know he's the first name on the team sheet ? I bet that's Green.

Otherwise, a fair assessment.

One game in how many mate??

[SuperHoopNik]

Spurs fans seem to think he's their saviour for next season. All they see is these great passing stats published all over sports sites, twitter etc. They don't see his flaws..very lightweight and crumbles under pressure. When we're playing well as a team he seems to at the heart of it at times, linking up nicely with the forwards and making some key passes. When we're not doing so well as a team he doesn't play so well either, he's a confidence player.

However, like I've said before, maybe he'd do better in the premier league where he'd arguably get more time and space, plus he'll be playing with much better players that he can learn off.