McClaren vs Redknapp:Which one would you have rather had as manager?.

[stan_bowles]

We had both at the club earlier in the season,so which one do you think would have given us the best chance at getting promoted?.

By the way,it's not an anti-Redknapp thread,just curious to see what fans think as McCclaren has taken Derby right in the mix.

[Nick]

We had both at the club earlier in the season,so which one do you think would have given us the best chance at getting promoted?.

By the way,it's not an anti-Redknapp thread,just curious to see what fans think as McCclaren has taken Derby right in the mix.

I no i'm probably going to be the only one who says this but its HR for me

Despite his successful spell with us Mcclaren will always be the wally with the brolly.

[twranger]

[QUOTE=stan_bowles;1231700]We had both at the club earlier in the season,so which one do you think would have given us the best chance at getting promoted?.

By the way,it's not an anti-Redknapp thread,just curious to see what fans think as McCclaren has taken Derby right in the mix.[/QUOTE]

...but still only a place ahead on GD (17/15) than us and played a game more than us.

[Brightsparx]

Mug thread

[fisnik]

[QUOTE=twranger;1231704]

We had both at the club earlier in the season,so which one do you think would have given us the best chance at getting promoted?.

By the way,it's not an anti-Redknapp thread,just curious to see what fans think as McCclaren has taken Derby right in the mix.[/QUOTE]

...but still only a place ahead on GD (17/15) than us and played a game more than us.

Don't see the point of asking people now with the benefit of hindsight. I think if asked at the time most fans whould have said HR.

But to answer your question. I think Harry would give us the better chance but who knows. I mean we could have gotten Mclaren and be first or relegated by now. Funny old game.

[Pie & mash]

Next up from Stan_bowles

Herpes or gonorrhea?... What would you rather catch?