Adel 15m price tag.

[James1979]

2 seasons in the prem has tarnished his rep tho...hope he stays next season but Prem player he aint.

I agree with you to an extent. I don't love him like some do on here but I do rate him more than you do. However, all sides do at least appreciate his impact on our promotion and the fact that he's been a qpr player for 100+ games. The two posters i was referring to do not it seems.

[James1979]

In fairness I think his copy book has been blotted by more then just pulling out of the wall going back to the Championship

The good far outweighs the bad for him in terms of what he's done on the pitch for us as a club. He's still young but he's a grown as a player and a person since the player that arrived on loan. I think he genuinely loves the club which is more than you an say for most of the players. Watch that interview after he scored that goal vs west ham. That is the type of player I want at my club.

[West Acton]

The good far outweighs the bad for him in terms of what he's done on the pitch for us as a club. He's still young but he's a grown as a player and a person since the player that arrived on loan. I think he genuinely loves the club which is more than you an say for most of the players. Watch that interview after he scored that goal vs west ham. That is the type of player I want at my club.

I hear what your saying but at what point do we stop paying penance to Adel for what he done three years ago and expect him to start contributing towards the team again. As it stands he has had two years grace for one years effort I personally don't call that outweighing what he has contributed and I like you like him as a player.

One thing I would disagree with you is that we cannot use the age thing as an excuse for him. He is 24 years of age top players are ripping up leagues at his age an influencing games week in week out Messi, Giggs, Rooney, Anelka etc

I think what we have in Adel is a good player/individual not an out of this world player that some make out he is.

I have said this previously but I think down at Rangers we have been brought up on the likes of Marsh, Bowles and Ferdinand and we are desperate for the next one of this sort to arrive so we latch onto anyone who shows any possibility of filling the void and hype them up; before Adel it was Buzsaky who I personally thought was pants especially when you actually break down what he delivered against how highly he was regarded

[James1979]

I hear what your saying but at what point do we stop paying penance to Adel for what he done three years ago and expect him to start contributing towards the team again. As it stands he has had two years grace for one years effort I personally don't call that outweighing what he has contributed and I like you like him as a player.

One thing I would disagree with you is that we cannot use the age thing as an excuse for him. He is 24 years of age top players are ripping up leagues at his age an influencing games week in week out Messi, Giggs, Rooney, Anelka etc

I think what we have in Adel is a good player/individual not an out of this world player that some make out he is.

I have said this previously but I think down at Rangers we have been brought up on the likes of Marsh, Bowles and Ferdinand and we are desperate for the next one of this sort to arrive so we latch onto anyone who shows any possibility of filling the void and hype them up; before Adel it was Buzsaky who I personally thought was pants especially when you actually break down what he delivered against how highly he was regarded

I also agree with you but we're qpr and to have players of his ability they will have rough edges. If he had attitude of a giggs or messi (not saying he's got their ability) he wouldn't be with us.

[acricketer]

£15m for Ralph Houston is too much

[West Acton]

I also agree with you but we're qpr and to have players of his ability they will have rough edges. If he had attitude of a giggs or messi (not saying he's got their ability) he wouldn't be with us.

I have you right with that comment about attitude. If he could sort out the attitude and his application I think he could seriously be whatever he wants but as you suggest attitude sorts out the good players from the world class players.

At the moment he has to score a goal or set up goals to justify his place in the team but If he could only add proper work rate to his game week in week out, tackling, leadership what a player he would be as without him scoring or creating he would still be contributing to the team. There appears to be no inbetween its either a Fulham barnstorming performance or a Reading one where he gave the ball away and fluffed every decent opportunity at goal