Not a video I’ve seen until after this evenings game against Burnley. Vale’s reasonably impressive first season seems to have gone against him this season with fans making him a scapegoat, he reminds me of another previous fans boo boy Mick Leach who I think never got the respect he deserved for his un selfish play and his knack of scoring important goals.
Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
Harvey Vale the New Boo Boy for the Fans
Collapse
X
-
I’ll admit not his biggest fan but v Burnley he was our best player in terms of going forwards and when he came off we were poor
His set pieces tbh are better than most and he’s kept fit since regaining fitness after signing, all clubs have so called boo boys I wouldn’t class most on here as that criticism comes in any way of life Madsen had it and won POS from it. I would say he’s got a Worldie goal in him as per stoke I think and another not many in this side have👍 1 -
I think of players in terms of Top Trumps cards, y'know, a mark out of 10 for various attributes like speed, skill, passing, shooting, tackling etc etc.
I see Vale as a load of 6s and 7s... adequate all round but no outstanding parts to his game other than maybe fitness, he seems one of the few players we have that doesn't need a week of recuperation after playing 4.5hrs of football in 8 days.
Putting in a 6 or 7 out of 10 performance as part of decent winning team performance is perfectly okay and acceptable. But putting in a 6 out of 7 during a limp, shot-shy and ineffectual team performance with a disappointing result at the end of it will inevitably draw a less favourable view of his night's work.
Personally, I think there was something wrong with the tactics and set-up last night - it was glaringly obvious what was going to happen after 20 minutes and I'm not convinced JS did very much during the game to change the direction of travel. In that sense I don't really hold any individual player accountable despite fact quite a few were not on top form. It was basically a poor team effort we need to put right on Saturday against a battling team who will actually be a harder proposition than the out-of-sorts Clarets.Comment
-
I hope my club, is above having a boo boy. That would be entirely negative and very mean spirited. We need to get behind everybody particularly those who might be struggling. Vale has some skill, but is not the “terrier” type player that we are missing. He could be a key player but to get the best from him and others, we need…..
a) A regular goal scoring CF and
b) A powerful driving midfielder/captain who can sort things out onfield.
Without both of those, we will, unfortunately, see recurring somewhat disappointing performances like last night.
A solution, from what we currently have, is, I fear, currently not available to us.👍 2Comment
-
Agree with youI hope my club, is above having a boo boy. That would be entirely negative and very mean spirited. We need to get behind everybody particularly those who might be struggling. Vale has some skill, but is not the “terrier” type player that we are missing. He could be a key player but to get the best from him and others, we need…..
a) A regular goal scoring CF and
b) A powerful driving midfielder/captain who can sort things out onfield.
Without both of those, we will, unfortunately, see recurring somewhat disappointing performances like last night.
A solution, from what we currently have, is, I fear, currently not available to us.Comment
-
I didnt hear Vale getting boos last night?
The midfield is collectively weak and missing a physical presence. Im not aware of anyone being picked out of the collective unit beyond online debate...?
I never realised signing a player in the mould of Shaun Derry would be so difficult. The intent is clearly to have a shop window of ball players over putting a winning team together.👍 1Comment
-
Yes Sheep. That seems highly likely. However that ethos, if indeed the club has it, is surely questionable. Given that the overall lack of team achievement therefore brought about, would not naturally lead to us being seen as an attractive shop window prospect.Comment
-
I don’t think we are particularly weak in MF areas, it’s up front scoring goals on a regular basis where the problem lies.
I would tend to agree with Stanfan with his comments about our right attacking side lacking any combination play we’ve seen regularly down the left.
For that reason I would like Stéphan to stop partnering Smith with Kone up top and go with Kone, Dembele and Poku in the short term.
Get Poku and Dembele combining and overloading defenders down the right side.
Comment
-
Go onto the other forums to see what they say about Vale’s peformance last night. Even with the use of a poll from all its members some p*****d up fans still called his performance pathetic.I didnt hear Vale getting boos last night?
The midfield is collectively weak and missing a physical presence. Im not aware of anyone being picked out of the collective unit beyond online debate...?
I never realised signing a player in the mould of Shaun Derry would be so difficult. The intent is clearly to have a shop window of ball players over putting a winning team together.
Comment
-
Every player gets it now and again. Apart from his recent four goals, Kone has been p1££ poor too. Varane let's players run through him if hes not up for it. Nardi & Walsh used to get pellers last season online, but were supported on the pitch. Every time Walsh made a save Id scream praise at him to boost his confidence. Nobody has mentioned Chair's open goal miss from the Kolli cutback, let alone his normal cutting in and flying a ball over the bar... again!
Criticism online is one thing, but I dont think actual booing of a player during a game is warranted. Most of the online criticism is frustration at dropping points and I suspect most who dish it out aggressively haven't put on a pair of boots since leaving school.
I would be amazed if Vale gets actual boos during a game and I doubt he even reads online forums. The only "feedback" hed be interested in is that of the coaching staff.Comment
-
I would agree on a lot of your points
Every player gets it now and again. Apart from his recent four goals, Kone has been p1££ poor too. Varane let's players run through him if hes not up for it. Nardi & Walsh used to get pellers last season online, but were supported on the pitch. Every time Walsh made a save Id scream praise at him to boost his confidence. Nobody has mentioned Chair's open goal miss from the Kolli cutback, let alone his normal cutting in and flying a ball over the bar... again!
Criticism online is one thing, but I dont think actual booing of a player during a game is warranted. Most of the online criticism is frustration at dropping points and I suspect most who dish it out aggressively haven't put on a pair of boots since leaving school.
I would be amazed if Vale gets actual boos during a game and I doubt he even reads online forums. The only "feedback" hed be interested in is that of the coaching staff.
Varane I would say has a definite tendency to switch off at times, but then if you look at the very small amount of actual football he’s played prior to joining I can accept he’s still learning, it’s probably fair to say the same about the likes of Kone, Vale and many others.
As Stéphan said in his interview I can see marked progress recently with the players recruited, problem is as a fan it’s very easy to carried away with our start to the season which included some favourable fixtures and start expecting too much too quick.
On your last point about Vale I don’t think it’s a coincidence that firstly Stéphan had spoken to him about his form and secondly he was much better last night after probably listening to what Stéphan said about him in the latest WLS interview.
Maybe more experienced older pros don’t listen to social media but would find it difficult to think younger players avoid it.
👍 1Comment
-
I'm sure young players get guidance on the outside influences and what can impact their mental health, and therefore performances. I know of one ex prem player who was "instructed" not to go into Birmingham when he was at Villa. I think theres even more to performance management these days that go way beyond physical training. Dont top footballers even have people to look after their social media accounts for them? I doubt they even see the "donkey" comments.
I would agree on a lot of your points
Varane I would say has a definite tendency to switch off at times, but then if you look at the very small amount of actual football he’s played prior to joining I can accept he’s still learning, it’s probably fair to say the same about the likes of Kone, Vale and many others.
As Stéphan said in his interview I can see marked progress recently with the players recruited, problem is as a fan it’s very easy to carried away with our start to the season which included some favourable fixtures and start expecting too much too quick.
On your last point about Vale I don’t think it’s a coincidence that firstly Stéphan had spoken to him about his form and secondly he was much better last night after probably listening to what Stéphan said about him in the latest WLS interview.
Maybe more experienced older pros don’t listen to social media but would find it difficult to think younger players avoid it.
If I was a young fragile pro, I wouldnt go anywhere social media and fans forums. Id only respect the opinions of those who have played at pro level too. I'd definately be a Scholes type and would do everything possible to avoid the BS from those who dont know anything about being a pro player.
Im sure Vale is doing just fine and is oblivious to what is being said about him online.Comment
Comment