Recall Manning in January?

[dogsrrs]

Don't let anybody go untill June !!
leave all our loanees where they are , and for f uck sake stop knocking anybody or anything for the sake of posting !! Just try to be satisfied with the progress this small skint club making we are punching well above our weight at the moment ,
Sermon over

[Shepherds Mush]

Bring him back and take Luongo out of the side.

[acricketer]

manning not pulling up any trees in rotherham , he got 2 good pens . i'd want to hear better things of him before he got in , in front of scowen

Superb insight and incisive dismissive crushing of other opinions.

[72bus]

manning not pulling up any trees in rotherham , he got 2 good pens . i'd want to hear better things of him before he got in , in front of scowen

[1973 ranger]

Brian. I have always struggled to see what he actually does that benefits the team. As for whipping boy no I think it is more about Cameron doing a better job than him in the same way Wells and Hemed instead of Smith who scored goals last season.

[Brian Wilson]

Poor ol Scowen...great signing last year to whipping boy this year.

[dogsrrs]

Ryan Manning has scored a couple of pens for them and all of a sudden we should recall him? Not sure he's any better than Scowen tbh.

I'll tell you this mate he certainly aint as good as Scowens never mind any better , Scowens had decent to good championship season last year now there's someone better ( Cameron ) and Scowens is shyte he hasn't been his level of last year but then the early games he played very few were up to much

[Stanley]

Not sure he's any better than Scowen tbh.

Different types of player, but he’s certainly scored a lot more goals for us.

[davieqpr]

The only time he ever gets a mention on Rotherham forums is team sheets and penalties.The fans want a new AM signed in January. He didn't do too well for us before he got loaned out. We will find out a lot more about him playing for Rotherham than we will sitting on our bench. Also one off the wage bill and every little helps. Being on loan didn't do Eze or Samuel any harm.

[jamesnutt]

ryan manning has scored a couple of pens for them and all of a sudden we should recall him? Not sure he's any better than scowen tbh.

loooooool has the sun got to your head. Levels between them. Scowen is a liability. Manning is one of our most talented players. Jn

[1973 ranger]

100% better player than Scowen who in my opinion is the player who should be nowhere a starter for us. Very limited and we play at a much slower pace when he is on the field

[Ginger Ninja]

Ryan Manning has scored a couple of pens for them and all of a sudden we should recall him? Not sure he's any better than Scowen tbh.

[uptheR's]

If we were stuck in mid-table with no real prospect of going up or down then I'd say leave him there. That was my opinion when he first went there as well. But if we are in with a shout of making top 6 I would like to see him back

[Rebel R's]

Rotherham are our rivals? Have you looked at the table recently?

Of course I have,6 points at the moment but I'm looking at the bigger picture,a long season still ahead of us and we certainly aren't safe from being involved in a relegation fight towards the end. I don't want Ryan Manning keeping them up at our expense

[James1979]

He is doing great at our rivals Rotherham, it's a no brainer, leave him there to help them stay up

Rotherham are our rivals? Have you looked at the table recently?