Do people honestly believe Hogan can replace Routledge???

[qpr_rich]

Routledge has talent and is a threat

Hogan might as well have one leg

Hogan may have had a good game against Blackpool but one good game does not make you a good player... his incredibly weak left foot makes it so easy for defenders to defend against even ramage would have a field day. I seriously cannot be bothered with QPR at the moment. For the first time ever I'm ashamed of the club that used to be part of my identity.

I'd rather we were in administration and lower leagues because at least I could still feel like a proud member of a proud club... I am sick of this club and I find myself jealous of other clubs who have what we used to have. Lastly, I feel sorry for those younger ones growing up around the mediocrity that is QPR... I grew up in the days of Crouch, Bircham and Furlong; we were hardly successful, but we had a bit of bottle and rangers fans would always relish another Saturday afternoon at Loftus Road, regardless of the off the field problems.

[Ginger Ninja]

hogan is a good player and still young. but if people think he is good enough to replace routledge, they are quite clearly deluded.

[qpr_rich]

Hogan's nearly 22... a mere 3 years younger than Routledge.

All this rubbish about Lee Cook and Ephraim replacing him, absolutely laughable

[Receed R]

hogan needs a run the team imo

he is very under rated by some

[qpr_rich]

He is also over rated by many

[Neil]

Potentially better than Routledge,only class I have seen from Routledge was at Exeter & that was 3rd tier team,Hogan showed class in that game too.

[dodge-stoke-r]

NO

[FurtiveFox]

Potentially yes. He is still raw but will only develop with games. Good pace and attitude. He does need to develop the technical side of his game but certainly worth giving a chance to.

[stanistheman]

He can't replace Routledge, because if both are playing to their best ability, the latter is streets ahead. However, both players are inconsistant.

[baz]

Ok in this Scenerio, where a decent number 9 is brought in to partner Simpson, Taarbat and Cook compete for the left side berth and Hogan and Buzacky for the right and Balanta can drop in as well when needed.

Is Routledge such a loss?

[UB5 Ranger]

He is also over rated by many

As was the Football mercenary that was wayne Routeledge!!

Will always go where the money is, will play well for 4/5 games then go back to not giving a toss

[qpr1882]

Hogan is a good player. He can replace Wayne. May not be as good YET but Hogan will be class in his time.

[jfish]

I rate Hogan to be honest

[Bluehoop]

Yes

[Nodge70]

:

Potentially better than Routledge,only class I have seen from Routledge was at Exeter & that was 3rd tier team,Hogan showed class in that game too.

Nurse!!!

Oh stop, please - my sides can't take your hilarity any more!!

But obviously you've all seen something that our many managers and coaches this season haven't. That Hogan is in fact BETTER than Routledge.

It's so obvious now that Routledge was in the team because he was WORSE than Hogan in the opinion of professional football staff. How dumb of them