Top Ten R's Of The Decade

[1973 ranger]

Think Henry could get in based on the play off season where he was good in the semi and final. Definitely in front of Phillips for me.

[corbray]

10. Djibril Cisse
9. Massimo Luongo
8. Richard Dunne
7. Shaun Derry
6. Paddy Kenny
5. Nedum Onuoha
4. Adel Taarabt
3. Charlie Austin
2. Alejandro Faurlin
1. Clint Hill

swap out cisse for smithies and that'd be my top 10

[bakes8]

10. Djibril Cisse
9. Massimo Luongo
8. Richard Dunne
7. Shaun Derry
6. Paddy Kenny
5. Nedum Onuoha
4. Adel Taarabt
3. Charlie Austin
2. Alejandro Faurlin
1. Clint Hill

Decent list that.

[Shepherds Mush]

Can't believe Martin Rowlands hasn't been mentioned.

[West Acton]

10. Djibril Cisse
9. Massimo Luongo
8. Richard Dunne
7. Shaun Derry
6. Paddy Kenny
5. Nedum Onuoha
4. Adel Taarabt
3. Charlie Austin
2. Alejandro Faurlin
1. Clint Hill

Good thread this

Question do you think those players if we added one extra player from last ten years would survive in the prem

[Norths]

Can't believe Martin Rowlands hasn't been mentioned.

Rowlands another one that fell out of favour from 2010-11 onwards. If we was talking previous decade then he would definitely be in contention.

[Norths]

Think Henry could get in based on the play off season where he was good in the semi and final. Definitely in front of Phillips for me.

Did he feature in the playoffs? Struggling to recall him playing but will hold my hand up if so. Henry was a decent servent to the club though, so probably would deserve a shout as a potential even if it's a slim chance of making the top ten.

[Alanwycombe]

Can't believe Martin Rowlands hasn't been mentioned.

Fans shirt of the season belonged to the guy with Rowlandinho on the back.

[Alanwycombe]

Would possibly reserve judgement on that one. Next season has the potential to be a big one for the likes of young Eze, Smyth, Oteh, BOS, Chair etc? Be interesting to return to this thread then...

What chance Shodipo being recalled to take his rightful place amongst that lot? Precious little I reckon. Two years ago, as Nasser in particular will remember, he was going to be the next great thing to come along for QPR. Gets shipped out to Port Vale after our wonderful manager criticised his defending! Even more of a stupid comment when you consider he said after Bidwell's penalty miss that he pays defenders to defend and forwards (err.... Like Shodipo?) to score goals. I'm not bothered about Goss, somebody's big mistake, because he will have made a few quid out of his transfer and will move on again, but Shodipo has been treated appallingly. Tell me he wouldn't have been worth a try like BOS? Quick, strong and one of our own.

[hal9thou]

Shodipo

Yeah, and he got that stick while Ollie was persisting with WBs [facepalm/]...... and then the buffoon opens that big mouth again to sl ag one of his own.

Unlike Eze though, I don't think Sho was ready last term and he could never have been involved in a WB set up.

[Shepherds Mush]

What chance Shodipo being recalled to take his rightful place amongst that lot? Precious little I reckon. Two years ago, as Nasser in particular will remember, he was going to be the next great thing to come along for QPR. Gets shipped out to Port Vale after our wonderful manager criticised his defending! Even more of a stupid comment when you consider he said after Bidwell's penalty miss that he pays defenders to defend and forwards (err.... Like Shodipo?) to score goals. I'm not bothered about Goss, somebody's big mistake, because he will have made a few quid out of his transfer and will move on again, but Shodipo has been treated appallingly. Tell me he wouldn't have been worth a try like BOS? Quick, strong and one of our own.

You have to wonder why Shodipo hasn't made more of his loan move like Eze did though.

[Alanwycombe]

Yeah, and he got that stick while Ollie was persisting with WBs [facepalm/]...... and then the buffoon opens that big mouth again to sl ag one of his own.

Unlike Eze though, I don't think Sho was ready last term and he could never have been involved in a WB set up.

Definitely not a WB but once Holloway - or Ramsey? - started playing four at the back Shodipo would have been a useful alternative to Wszolek who has gone backwards since being messed about as a WB himself.

[Alanwycombe]

You have to wonder why Shodipo hasn't made more of his loan move like Eze did though.

Hmmm.....but Shodipo had played a few games so shipping him out must have hit his confidence where Eze was still building his. Also, where would you rather go - Wycombe to play under Ainsworth or Port Vale to sit on the bench?

[Timmy the Doc]

10. Djibril Cisse
9. Massimo Luongo
8. Richard Dunne
7. Shaun Derry
6. Paddy Kenny
5. Nedum Onuoha
4. Adel Taarabt
3. Charlie Austin
2. Alejandro Faurlin
1. Clint Hill

Smithies instead of Kenny for me.

[Shepherds Mush]

In the short time he was with us I thought Ryan Nelsen was absolute quality.