Charlie's penno yesterday....

[BuffooneRy]

Anyone else think he made the most of that one? If that was against us we'd be up in arms....

Not sure where I'm going with this maybe I was thinking what other fans would say....

[KuPR]

Anyone else think he made the most of that one? If that was against us we'd be up in arms....

Not sure where I'm going with this maybe I was thinking what other fans would say....

No, absolutely nailed on pen for me

[Mattyqpr]

Anyone else think he made the most of that one? If that was against us we'd be up in arms....

Not sure where I'm going with this maybe I was thinking what other fans would say....

I say you're mad! Nailed on!

[Jimmy Floyd Rabbit]

Marney hung a leg out in the box. Fatal error. Pen.

[BuffooneRy]

He looked pretty eager to go down to me but as you say the fella's leg was there.....

Anyway it shouldn't detract from the fact that Harry should be gone by tomorrow afternoon at the very latest, for me anyway..... Off to bed and no doubt I will dream that we can stay up and I might as well make the most of it as that could be the closest we do get to staying up.....

[gator]

Looked a penalty to me, I've seen them not given though obviously!

[dsqpr]

Anyone else think he made the most of that one? If that was against us we'd be up in arms....

Not sure where I'm going with this maybe I was thinking what other fans would say....

He was tripped. Nailed on pen for me.

[march56]

Definite pen

[Ginger Ninja]

Stonewall

[BuffooneRy]

Fair enough I'm outvoted on this one....

[Abseits]

Its one of them where different things apply cos its in the box..... Majority of players would just burst through that sort of wishy-washy challenge if it occurred on the half way line but once it happens in the box majority of players go over.

[vanhoop]

PENNO? c'mon buffy that sounds right mincy,pull ya socks up lad xx

[BuffooneRy]

PENNO? c'mon buffy that sounds right mincy,pull ya socks up lad xx

Sorry sweetie I'll try and be more Wilkins(Butch) in future....

[BuffooneRy]

Its one of them where different things apply cos its in the box..... Majority of players would just burst through that sort of wishy-washy challenge if it occurred on the half way line but once it happens in the box majority of players go over.

Excellent summary.....

[dsqpr]

Fair enough I'm outvoted on this one....

Don't worry, if you ask ten fans about any penalty decision this season you'd get hardly any where all would agree! I always think it's fun seeing what others thought about a penalty decision and comparing it to my own analysis.